Eddie, Dave, Alex and Wolfie in NYC

It must have been around 8:40 or so by the time I finally located the bar in Madison Square Garden where I could get liquor. The home of the New York Rangers had beer everywhere, of course, but only the bar had whiskey. I'd have plenty of time to grab a couple Jamesons, head back to our seats above the right side of the stage and wait for the opening act to go on.
Sound from the main auditorium trickled into the bar. "Hey, is that VH playin?"
"Naw," I said, looking up at one of the ubiquitous middle-aged white baseball cap wearin’ jarheads who had flooded the venue that night for the long-awaited Van Halen show. "There's an opening act." I'd confirmed that with three or four security guys; plus there was a T-shirt for sale featuring whoever the opening act was at the merch table. There'd better be a goddam opener.
Well, the drinks came in the next minute or two, and I hightailed it outta there heading back to the auditorium, as VH's cover of the Kinks’s “You Really Got Me” became more and more audible. "Fuck! Damn it! ARGGGHHH!" It wasn't supposed to happen like this!
So, that was how the show started for me. Turned out the "opening act" was the DJ playing the crap before the band took the stage.
To describe what we heard that night, I'm not going to rattle off a set list or lay down any of that tediously pompous rock criticism type stuff I can't stand. But I can offer a glimpse into what I experienced and dug the most.
I’ll Wait… and Wait… and Wait
My overall conclusion is there's no way to compare this show to any other. I mean, not only am I accustomed to seeing and hearing bands in bars and small clubs, we’d anticipated this show for years. This was Van Halen playing with the only vocalist that counted: David Lee Roth. This was The Eddie Van Halen. The Alex Van Halen. Living legends!
The only non-original member was Wolfgang, Eddie’s teenage son, replacing Michael Anthony. The only thing we’d really be missing there were Anthony’s awesome high-end backup vocals. Yeah, I definitely did miss those.
The true test, in addition to how they sounded (really, really great), would be their stage presence. Would the notoriously feuding Eddie and Dave last through the show without at least sneering at one another? Yes! Indeed, Dave and Eddie were all smiles, literally. Eddie had a giant grin on his face the whole time. And surely that was partly ‘cause his young son was on stage with him at Madison Square Garden, but so be it.
Hammer On
Musically, the highlight for me was the obvious one: Eddie’s extended guitar solo interlude. At one point in the show he was left onstage alone, sitting on an amp (I think), tugging on a smoke. He stamped it out with his red sneaker (Converse?) and began fiddling. That soon erupted into a powerful, sometimes raging solo, hammer-ons galore.
His brother had done his requisite drum solo earlier. Both lasted longer than I would have expected, and I have to say I was pleased by that since before I had assumed giant shows like these were created with the lowest common denominator in mind rather than the true appreciator of the musicianship involved. OK, it’s not like these guys were playing avant-garde jazz or anything, but you know what I mean.
They played all the tunes you wanted to hear: 1984 classics like “Hot for Teacher” and “Panama,” early stuff like “Everybody Wants Some,” less-expected songs like “Little Dreamer” and “Little Guitars” (always one of my faves). I think I liked “Ain’t Talkin’ ‘Bout Love” the best though. It hit me that way, just kicked in right.
Pasadena and a Dude Named Kenny
We’d heard from a friend of a friend a week or so earlier that when he caught the tour elsewhere, Dave didn’t address the crowd. Not so for us. The moment I loved most was one of his orchestrated spiels. It came during his quasi-solo, during which he played his signature tune, “Ice Cream Man,” acoustic guitar in hand. His intro, I’m sure mostly scripted, was a tale of youthful innocence and teen lust. Kids getting high in somebody’s tree house, a dude named “Kenny” who lived above the garage, somethin’ like that. Somebody in the neighborhood parked his ice cream truck in the driveway every night. Whatever -- the typical Dave rambling ya gotta love.
“I grew up in Pasadena, California,” he announced. “You know -- the suburbs -- where they tear out all the trees and name the streets after ‘em.” It went somethin’ like that. I’ve been repeating that line to people since the show, but most people just smirk. They don’t dig it as much as I do. Then again, it’s me saying it, not the man with the silver tongue.
Rock ‘n’ Roll Snow Globe
I expected not to like a few things. The distracting giant screen featuring close-ups of the band I could do without, but folks sitting in the nose-bleeds probably appreciated it. My biggest beef: the damn piped-in synthesizer. Two songs demand keyboards – “I’ll Wait” and the encore, “Jump.” Rather than get a real live keyboardist to play Eddie’s part, the synthesizer parts were canned and played through the sound system. There were times when things weren’t perfectly synced, and just sounded off to me. I was annoyed with that, even though I enjoyed hearing both tunes.
Before “Jump,” though, the crowd was doused with confetti, out of which Dave emerged on a giant, inflatable microphone, larger than life. It felt like we were all in a giant rock ‘n’ roll snow globe.
One totally unexpected highlight was chatting with Craig Wedren of Shudder to Think fame after the show. I passed by him on my way to the bathroom and peeked back out, “Didn’t you used to sing for Shudder to Think?” Yep. Super cool guy. He, by the way, loved “I’ll Wait.” So what the hell do I know.